July is the cheapest month to fly this route, with average fares around $335 round trip.
Average round-trip fares by departure month, based on current availability.
| Month | Avg Price | Lowest | Relative Cost | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 2026 | $355 | $330 | Peak | |
| June 2026 | $339 | $318 | ||
| July 2026 | $335 | $330 | Best | |
| August 2026 | $336 | $330 |
Departing on Tuesday offers the lowest average fares at $334. Thursday departures are the most expensive at $351, a difference of $17.
The best time to fly is July. Set up an alert and we'll notify you when prices drop.
Get Started Free →The cheapest month to fly from New York to Montego Bay is July, with average round-trip fares around $335. The lowest fare found in July is $330.
Tuesday departures are the cheapest, averaging $334 round trip. The most expensive day is Thursday at $351.
Based on current pricing trends, booking for July travel offers the best value. Avoid May if possible, as fares average $355 compared to $335 in the cheapest month. June is a solid middle-ground option at $339.
Flying in July instead of May can save you approximately $20 per round trip. The cheapest month averages $335 while the most expensive averages $355.
Airlines, flight times, price calendar, and more for New York to Montego Bay
View JFK → MBJ Details